Showing posts with label China. Show all posts
Showing posts with label China. Show all posts

Friday, July 29, 2011

The Debt Debate and China

Republicans are being horrible politicians during this contentious and polarized debt debate. Let us be honest, they have not been willing to compromise adequately with the democrats. The Freshman Republicans claim that they were sent to Washington by the Tea Partiers to decrease the debt and put the government on track to become financially self-sufficient, i.e. spending money that we take in from revenue from American citizens. Borrowing from foreign nations, like scary China, is unacceptable to these politicians and for good reason.

But let us put this into perspective and context. China needs us just as much as we need them. There is a reason why they are willing to take in American debt and accumulate a foreign reserve surplus while we run a deficit. China needs America to export a vast amount of their products into our vibrant economy. America's economy is based on 70% consumption and China wants to be a main provider for that 70%. A problem in this dangerously dependent relationship is that if one of us decides to stop playing in this game it could be detrimental to both economies. For instance, if China were to stop buying our debt or demanded faster repayments in the form of higher interest rates it would hurt the American economy. But the point is that even though China owns a substantial amount of debt, I think it is around 8%, they don't have as much leverage as the fiscal situation implicates. An underlying reason why China's economy has been growing at 9% annually is because they began opened themselves up to foreign markets with America being their most significant client.

The China debacle explained to some extent in the previous paragraph is just to get who ever may end up reading this a different way to view our complicated relationship with China. Now, back to the debt debate. All members from both parties acknowledge the fact that increasing an already 14 trillion dollars of debt is dangerous. All congressman are attempting to mitigate our debt problem, it is just the variables that we take to do that that they disagree on.

Republicans have legitimacy behind their statement of "increasing taxes incentivizes the government to spend more." In the past, taxes have been increased as well as spending and decreasing the debt never materialized. But in the Clinton Administration, they balanced the budget while increasing some taxes and put the country on a path of domestic fiscal solvency. And Obama has been willing to decrease the debt by 4 trillion over the next ten years. Some members of Congress call his speech disingenuous. But Obama had a 4 trillion dollar plan that was rejected by Congress. Obama has held meetings daily to find a solution and has himself tied an otherwise unconnected debt ceiling with the fiscal budget. This does not have to be done, but Obama wants to chip away at our debt. He has acted as such. And please, pray that a deal gets done, and if your agnostic or atheist, call someone who is religious and ask them to pray for you. 

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Why Americans Should Not Care about China

The United States needs to embrace the possibility that it may not be the most powerful nation in the world forever. China, for instance, causes a lot of unnecessary anxiety in many Americans who fear that China may overtake “their” number one spot on the international stage. However, when Great Britain was forced to hand over the reigns to the US after losing the top position in the 20th century, they still were able to remain influential in the world, with their people still living relatively prosperous. What the US needs to do with regards to China is make sure that they do not try to overthrow the current international system, which is highly unlikely for a number of reasons. 
China has taken some insignificant steps that could be interpreted as steps to overhaul the current international system. They just recently have been adamant about controlling the East China and South China seas. However, the international community intervened and responded to China’s shift in naval policy offering to help settle the disputes surrounding the seas islands and resources. 
What’s more, China has an incentive to maintain the current international system. China has already experienced the benefits of participating in the international organizations, such as the WTO, as well as the IMF, where their percentage of votes increased to 3.6% in 2006 from 2.9%. eConversely, skeptics contend that China may want to transform the international system to punish the West for rectification because of past discriminatory actions taken by the West. Many of the acts that were perceived by the Chinese as oppressive occurred during the 19th century, such as the Opium trade that the West trafficked into China. More recently, in the 20th century, the US made sure that after WWII China was granted a permanent seat on the UN Security Council and created institutions that guarded against discriminatory acts and unfair policies, which further established China as a recognized world power, as well as additional protection from the West for developing countries. 
Furthermore, it is not inevitable that China becomes the next hegemon. Remember, China also has severe domestic problems that they have to face. Thus, Americans should not overreact to what they perceive as an eventual usurpation of influence in the world. China has skyrocketing rates of pollution and environmental degradation, soaring unemployment, rampant corruption, a social welfare net in tatters, and rising income inequalities. Moreover, China’s population-control policy will soon have dramatic effects in the upcoming years in tending with their rapidly increasing senior class accompanied by an insufficient labor force.
What the US did post World War II was establish international institutions that brought countries closer together with the objective of avoiding future wars between great powers. As well, the proliferation of nuclear weapons has made war between great powers even more unlikely. Also, the Western system is not run solely by one hegemon, but by a number of powers who continuously engage with one another, compromise with each other, and come to conclusions together, instead of one hegemon or empire dictating the rules to all. Moreover, the system is designed to accommodate rising world powers. For instance, the IMF and the World Bank give institutional voice in these organizations based on economic shares. In other words, as an economy gets larger, the percentage of votes in these respective institutions gets larger. This also means that if China were to overtake the US as the strongest world power, the US would still have an influential voice in these institutions if they were to continue to be a great power. Thus, it is more important for the US to focus on internal problems than worrying about China overtaking them as the top world power. 
Moreover, the sheer number of countries that benefit from the current international system make it even more unlikely for China to try and overhaul the system. For example, the US and the Europe Union each have a strong incentive to maintain the current system. Thus, the balance of power scenario of a declining hegemon and a rising one is not the entire story in this situation. Multiple nations have benefited from this system and will be reluctant to change it. In essence, the US should not invest in making sure it is the sole hegemon because the repercussions that could manifest in a change of power are not as severe as past changes of power, where any new hegemon completely altered the international system. 
In conclusion, what the US needs to do is not necessarily focus on China, but on the current international order, as well as their domestic issues. The US must reinvest and show support for the current international system. This would include pushing for a solution in the current Doha Round of trade talks, which is mainly hinged on developing countries wanting to enter into Western markets. The US should advocate for the abolition of agricultural subsidies to domestic agriculture industries in all developed nations for a solution to be reached. This will enhance developing countries support for the current international system.  Also, the US should not overextend itself because of fear that China will overtake the Unites States’ position because the international changes will be minimal compared to past transitions of power.